Your roof is your home’s main defense against the elements, so choosing the right shingles is critical. Asphalt shingles are the most popular roofing material in the U.S., covering about 80% of homes thanks to their balance of durability, affordability, and ease of installation. But not all asphalt shingles are the same. Here’s a breakdown of five leading brands – GAF, Owens Corning, CertainTeed, TAMKO, and Atlas – to help you make an informed decision:
- GAF: Known for its industry-leading warranties and wind resistance, GAF shingles are ideal for high-wind areas. Their Timberline HDZ shingles cost $6–$9 per sq. ft. installed.
- Owens Corning: Features a reinforced nailing zone for better wind resistance and durability. Pricing ranges from $450–$550 per square installed.
- CertainTeed: A premium option with heavy, durable shingles and top-tier warranties. Expect to pay $5–$11 per sq. ft. installed, depending on the product line.
- TAMKO: A budget-friendly choice, suitable for short-term use or rental properties. Costs range from $70–$90 per square.
- Atlas: Specializes in algae-resistant shingles, perfect for humid climates. Prices fall between $85–$120 per square.
Quick Comparison
| Brand | Price (Installed) | Wind Rating | Algae Warranty | Durability | Best For |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| GAF | $6–$9/sq. ft. | 130+ mph | 25–30 years | 25–30 years | High-wind areas, certified installation |
| Owens Corning | $450–$550/square | 130 mph | 10–25 years | 25–30 years | High winds, hail-prone regions |
| CertainTeed | $5–$11/sq. ft. | 110–130 mph | 15 years | 25–50 years | Premium durability, aesthetics |
| TAMKO | $70–$90/square | 110 mph | 15 years | 20–30 years | Budget-conscious projects |
| Atlas | $85–$120/square | 130–150 mph | Lifetime (Scotchgard) | 20–50 years | Humid areas, algae resistance |
When choosing shingles, consider your local climate, budget, and long-term goals. Proper installation by certified contractors is key to maximizing performance and warranties.
Asphalt Shingle Comparison CertainTeed, GAF, Owens Corning and Atlas by Redeem Roofing Burlington NC
sbb-itb-e0ea4e0
1. GAF Roofing Shingles
GAF holds a commanding presence in North America’s roofing market, capturing 25–30% of the residential segment [2]. Since its founding in 1886, GAF has built its reputation on an extensive contractor network and a warranty system that scales with installer certification. Their Timberline HDZ shingles are the top-selling roofing product in North America [13].
Protect your home with professional roofing services built for long term durability.
Warranty
GAF offers a tiered warranty system that depends on contractor certification. At the highest level, the Golden Pledge Warranty provides 50 years of fully non-prorated material coverage and 25 years of workmanship protection. However, only Master Elite contractors – representing just 2% of roofing professionals nationwide [2] – can offer this warranty.
What sets GAF apart is their WindProven Limited Wind Warranty, which provides unlimited wind speed protection when installed with four specific GAF components: starter strips, roof deck protection, ridge cap shingles, and either a leak barrier or attic ventilation [4]. While most competitors limit their wind warranties to 110–130 mph, GAF goes further. Additionally, their StainGuard Plus technology includes a 25-year warranty against algae discoloration, showcasing GAF’s focus on longevity and aesthetics [1].
This tiered warranty system, combined with advanced wind resistance features, positions GAF as a standout in the roofing industry.
Wind Resistance
GAF employs LayerLock Technology, which uses woven fabric strips embedded through the shingle layers instead of relying solely on adhesives [2]. Paired with Dura Grip Adhesive and a StrikeZone nailing area – which is 600% larger than standard – this design ensures highly accurate nail placement, with a 99.9% precision rate [7].
"GAF is recognized as the market leader for wind resistance among roofing manufacturers, with their WindProven limited warranty covering winds up to 130 mph with no maximum wind speed limitation." – County Roofing Systems [2]
Standard Timberline shingles are rated for 130 mph winds, but when installed as part of a complete system, the WindProven warranty eliminates any wind speed cap [7]. This makes GAF an excellent choice for homes in high-wind areas, such as those along the Gulf Coast.
Durability
GAF’s Timberline shingles are made with fiberglass-reinforced asphalt, giving them a lifespan of 25–30 years [2][9]. While testing by the IBHS showed that Timberline HDZ shingles scored 6.7 for hail resistance – lower than Owens Corning Duration’s 8.0 – GAF offers impact-resistant options like Timberline AS II and Timberline UHDZ, which hold UL 2218 Class 4 ratings, making them suitable for hail-prone regions [4].
The cost of Timberline HDZ shingles is approximately $100–$135 per square, translating to around $6.00–$9.00 per sq. ft. installed [9]. For a typical 2,000 sq. ft. roof, homeowners can expect to pay between $12,000 and $18,000 [11]. Compared to CertainTeed Landmark shingles of similar quality, GAF is typically 5–10% more affordable [1]. This balance of durability and cost makes GAF a reliable choice for harsh weather conditions.
Best For
GAF shingles are ideal for homeowners who prioritize wind resistance and certified installation, particularly in coastal or high-wind areas.
2. Owens Corning Roofing Shingles
Owens Corning holds a strong position in the residential roofing market, commanding about 15–20% of it. Known for their engineering expertise, they’ve developed the Duration series, which features their patented SureNail Technology. This technology incorporates a woven fabric strip that reinforces a 6–7 inch nailing zone, creating a triple-layer system where the fabric, shingle, and underlayment meet. This design not only prevents nail pull-through but also provides contractors with a precise guide for fastening [2][7][12].
Warranty
Owens Corning ties its warranties to contractor certification and the use of a complete system. Their Platinum Protection warranty, available exclusively through Platinum Preferred contractors, includes 50 years of non-prorated material coverage and 25 years of workmanship protection [2]. The TRU PROtection Period covers labor and material costs for the first 10 years without depreciation [6][12].
Standard Duration shingles come with a 130 mph wind warranty and 10 years of StreakGuard Algae Resistance Protection. This algae protection is achieved using copper-lined granules to combat dark streaks caused by cyanobacteria [2][12]. For homeowners who install a complete Owens Corning system – shingles plus at least three qualifying accessories like underlayment and starter strips – tiered warranty options (Standard, Preferred, and Platinum) are available. However, extended warranties require registration with the manufacturer [7][12].
Wind Resistance
Owens Corning’s SureNail fabric strip is designed to handle high winds. Unlike adhesive-only systems, this reinforcement distributes stress more evenly, reducing the risk of shingles blowing off during storms [2][7]. Duration shingles carry a 130 mph wind rating, but achieving this requires a 6-nail application pattern along with Owens Corning’s specific starter and ridge shingles [7][12].
"SureNail Technology revolutionized shingle installation by creating a reinforced nailing zone that improves wind resistance and reduces installation errors." – County Roofing Systems [2]
This technology is particularly effective in coastal areas, where wind-driven rain and strong gusts can challenge shingle adhesion [2][5].
From inspections to full replacements, our roofing team delivers dependable results.
Durability
Beyond wind resistance, Owens Corning shingles are built for long-term durability. Standard Duration shingles, made with fiberglass-reinforced asphalt, have a lifespan of 25–30 years [12]. For areas prone to hail, the Duration Storm and Duration Flex lines are rated UL 2218 Class 4 for impact resistance [7][10]. The Duration Flex line goes a step further by using SBS-modified asphalt, which makes the shingles flexible enough to withstand impacts and extreme temperatures without cracking [7][5].
Owens Corning also focuses on maintaining consistent colors. Their TruDefinition Color platform ensures uniformity across batches, which is crucial for repairs or extensions to an existing roof [2]. For homeowners in hot climates, the Duration Premium Cool line can lower roof surface temperatures by up to 20°F. Additionally, Energy Star certified colors like Shasta White can reduce peak cooling demands by 10–15% [7][2].
Pricing ranges from $100–$120 per square for the Oakridge line to $145–$180 per square for Duration Flex [7]. Installed costs for standard Duration shingles typically fall between $450–$550 per square, offering a balance of advanced fastening technology and competitive pricing [7].
Best For
Owens Corning shingles are a great choice for homeowners in areas prone to high winds or hail. Their reinforced fastening system reduces installation errors, while the Class 4 impact-resistant options may help homeowners qualify for insurance discounts in severe weather zones. To maximize warranty benefits, it’s important to work with a contractor who holds Preferred or Platinum certification [2][10][12].
3. CertainTeed Roofing Shingles
CertainTeed ranks as the second-largest shingle manufacturer in North America by volume, but many roofing professionals regard it as the gold standard for quality. Their shingles are known for being exceptionally durable. For example, the Landmark series weighs around 230 lbs per square, while their premium lines surpass 400 lbs per square. This heft adds extra protection against issues like cupping, cracking, and hail damage [2][9].
One standout feature is CertainTeed’s QuadraBond technology. Unlike most manufacturers that use one or two adhesive strips, CertainTeed applies four sealant bands to each shingle. This design significantly increases the bonding surface, offering better protection against wind-driven rain and shingle blow-off [2]. Combined with their robust construction, this innovation supports their industry-leading warranties.
Warranty
CertainTeed is often praised for offering some of the most thorough warranties in the business. Their coverage includes all manufacturing defects, not just those that lead to active leaks [15]. Their SureStart™ Protection covers all material, labor, and disposal costs for manufacturing defects during the first 10–15 years [16][8]. For those who hire a SELECT ShingleMaster certified contractor and install a complete CertainTeed system, the SureStart Plus warranty extends non-prorated coverage to 10 years and adds up to 25 years of workmanship protection [6][10][2].
Standard Landmark shingles come with a limited lifetime warranty that’s transferable to future homeowners [17][6]. Additionally, the StreakFighter algae resistance warranty lasts 10–15 years, depending on the product, and uses copper-infused granules to combat dark streaks from cyanobacteria [9][2]. This algae protection period is longer than the 10 years offered by many competitors’ entry-level shingles [2].
"CertainTeed is widely recognized as a premier manufacturer of exterior building materials and a winner of the Professional Remodelers Best in Class award." – RoofingCalc.com [9]
Proper installation is essential to fully benefit from these warranties. Beyond their comprehensive coverage, CertainTeed shingles are also designed to perform well in high-wind conditions.
Wind Resistance
CertainTeed’s premium shingles are built to withstand winds up to 110 mph, with an optional upgrade to 130 mph when paired with specific starter shingles and ridge caps [9][10][2]. Their QuadraBond adhesive system, with its four points of contact, ensures wind stress is distributed evenly across the shingle layers. This makes them particularly effective in coastal areas where strong winds and heavy rain are common [2].
Durability
Durability is another hallmark of CertainTeed shingles. Standard Landmark shingles are expected to last 25–30 years, while premium lines installed by certified contractors can deliver 30–50 years of performance [8][3]. For regions prone to hail, CertainTeed offers Class 4 impact-resistant shingles like Presidential IR and Landmark IR, which can endure hits from 2-inch hailstones without cracking [10]. All CertainTeed shingles also carry a Class A fire resistance rating [15].
With over 40 color options, CertainTeed provides the widest range of choices among major manufacturers. Their shingles are also known for their dimensional appearance and rich color depth [10][2]. In hot climates, the Landmark Solaris line reflects up to 40% of solar heat, helping to reduce cooling costs [2].
Of course, this level of quality comes at a premium. CertainTeed shingles generally cost 10–15% more than competitors like GAF [10]. Landmark series shingles are priced at $110–$140 per square installed ($5.00–$7.00 per sq. ft.), while Landmark Premium costs $150–$180 per square installed ($6.00–$8.00 per sq. ft.). Luxury lines, such as Grand Manor, start at $250–$300+ per square installed ($8.00–$11.00 per sq. ft.) [2].
Best For
CertainTeed is an excellent option for homeowners who value long-term durability and high-end aesthetics over upfront cost. Their shingles perform particularly well in humid or coastal areas where algae resistance and wind protection are crucial [16][8][5]. However, because CertainTeed shingles are heavier than most, it’s essential to ensure your roof deck is in good shape before installation – especially on steep slopes where the weight could cause issues [9].
To unlock the strongest warranty options, it’s recommended to work with a SELECT ShingleMaster certified contractor. This ensures proper installation and provides access to the full System PLUS coverage [2][10]. Overall, CertainTeed offers a well-balanced combination of durability, performance, and aesthetics that appeals to homeowners seeking top-tier roofing solutions.
4. TAMKO Roofing Shingles
TAMKO is a go-to option for homeowners looking for a cost-effective and reliable roofing solution. The brand offers two main product lines: the Heritage series, which emphasizes affordability, and the Titan XT series, designed to handle harsher weather conditions [15]. This makes TAMKO a practical choice for straightforward roof replacements, rental properties, or homes that might be sold within 5–10 years [5]. By focusing on essential performance features, TAMKO appeals to those prioritizing budget over extra bells and whistles.
Despite its affordability, TAMKO covers the basics well, offering products that address durability, wind resistance, and warranty – key considerations for any roofing material.
Warranty
TAMKO’s warranties range from 10 to 30 years. However, they lack the extended non-prorated coverage typically found in premium brands [3].
Wind Resistance
The Heritage series is rated for wind resistance up to 110 mph, which might not be sufficient for areas prone to hurricanes or high winds [3]. On the other hand, the Titan XT series offers enhanced performance, making it a better fit for regions that experience frequent storms [15].
Durability
TAMKO shingles are made with fiberglass-reinforced asphalt, giving them a lifespan of 20 to 30 years. They meet Class A fire standards and are designed to reflect solar heat, which can help lower cooling costs in warmer climates [3][15]. However, compared to premium shingles, they may show signs of wear sooner [14].
Best For
TAMKO is an excellent choice for rental properties, budget-conscious homeowners, or straightforward roofing projects where keeping costs low is the main goal. With material costs ranging from $90 to $150 per square, TAMKO sits on the lower end of the price spectrum compared to mid-tier and premium brands [14]. Ideal for short-term investments or budget-friendly projects, TAMKO combines dependable performance with a wallet-friendly price point [5].
5. Atlas Roofing Shingles
Atlas Roofing has built its name around one key feature: algae resistance. By partnering with 3M, Atlas incorporates Scotchgard Protector technology into its shingles, such as the Pinnacle Pristine line, effectively targeting black streaks caused by blue-green algae – an issue common in humid, coastal climates [3][5][6]. Notably, Atlas is the only manufacturer using the 3M Scotchgard brand name, and this technology comes with a lifetime limited warranty against algae growth [18][2]. Since its founding in 1982, Atlas has focused on creating solutions tailored to specific climates [6].
In addition to algae resistance, Atlas shingles are built for durability. They’re thicker and heavier than many budget options, and their StormMaster line utilizes polymer-modified asphalt, which adds flexibility and impact resistance. This design helps the shingles better handle hail and other severe weather conditions [6].
Warranty
Atlas provides limited lifetime warranties against manufacturing defects, with coverage periods ranging from 10 to 50 years depending on the product line [3][6]. The Scotchgard warranty specifically ensures protection against algae streaks for a substantial portion of the roof’s lifespan [3][6]. This warranty aligns with the 50-year non-prorated material warranties offered by competitors like GAF and CertainTeed, when installed by certified contractors [3][2].
Wind Resistance
Atlas shingles are designed to withstand high winds, with most architectural shingles rated for speeds up to 130 mph, meeting industry standards for performance [3]. The premium StormMaster Shake and Slate lines go even further, handling gusts up to 150 mph and earning a Class H rating [19][20][22]. This durability is supported by HP42 technology, which includes a wider shingle format, a 1.5-inch "Sweet Spot" nailing area for precise fastening, and a double FASTAC sealant line to prevent uplift during storms [19][21].
Durability
Atlas shingles strike a balance between asphalt shingles pros and cons regarding cost and long-term performance, with lifespans ranging from 20 to 50 years depending on the product and local weather conditions [3]. The StormMaster line is particularly notable for its impact resistance, showing up to 127% better mechanical uplift resistance [19]. Core4 technology further enhances durability, offering 52% greater fastener pull-through resistance and 45% better tear strength compared to standard requirements [19]. Material costs typically fall between $85 and $120 per square, making these shingles both durable and budget-conscious [3][6].
Best For
Atlas shingles are a solid choice for homeowners in humid or coastal regions where algae growth is a frequent concern [3][5][6]. The brand also appeals to those seeking a balance of premium durability and affordability, earning recognition as a "Best Value" option in some industry evaluations [6]. For homes in hail-prone or high-wind areas, the StormMaster line offers top-tier protection with its 150 mph wind warranty and Class 4 impact resistance [21][22].
Advantages and Disadvantages by Brand
Every roofing brand has its own set of strengths and trade-offs, which often depend on factors like location, budget, and long-term goals. Here’s a quick breakdown to help you compare the options.
GAF leads the market with a 25–30% share and stands out for its Golden Pledge program. This includes a 25-year workmanship guarantee – far exceeding the typical 1–2 years offered by most competitors [2].
Owens Corning is known for its SureNail technology, which uses a reinforced fabric nailing zone. This innovation prevents nail pull-through and achieves a 130 mph wind rating with just 4 nails instead of the usual 6 [2][24].
CertainTeed markets itself as a premium brand. Its Landmark series shingles weigh about 230 lbs per square, making them heavier than most alternatives. This extra weight enhances durability and gives a more dimensional appearance [2].
TAMKO appeals to budget-conscious homeowners. While it offers reliable performance, it falls short in wind resistance (110 mph) and has a shorter algae warranty of 15 years compared to other premium options [3][23].
Atlas focuses on algae resistance, thanks to its partnership with 3M. Certain product lines come with a lifetime Scotchgard warranty, making Atlas the only manufacturer to use the 3M brand name. This feature is especially beneficial in humid climates, though availability may be limited in some regions [23][2][25].
"95% of roofing problems stem from installation defects, not manufacturing defects." – WeatherShield Roofing [27]
| Brand | Strength | Weakness | Price Range (per sq) | Wind Rating | Algae Warranty |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| GAF | Top-tier warranties and contractor network [3][27] | Higher cost than competitors [25] | $100–$130 | 130 mph | 25–30 years |
| Owens Corning | Reinforced nailing zone for better installation [3][25] | Shorter algae warranty [18] | $90–$120 | 130 mph | 10–25 years |
| CertainTeed | Heavy shingles with premium aesthetics [3][18] | Highest price point [3] | $150–$200 | 110–130 mph | 15 years |
| TAMKO | Budget-friendly with reliable performance [3][26] | Lower wind resistance [3] | $70–$90 | 110 mph | 15 years |
| Atlas | Superior algae resistance (Scotchgard) [3][26] | Limited regional availability [25] | $85–$120 | 130 mph | Lifetime |
This comparison highlights the key features and drawbacks of each brand. Whether you prioritize warranties, durability, price, or algae resistance, there’s an option tailored to your needs. GAF is a leader in warranty protection, Owens Corning offers innovative solutions at a reasonable price, CertainTeed delivers unmatched durability, TAMKO provides affordable reliability, and Atlas is ideal for areas prone to algae growth. Use this guide to make an informed decision for your roofing project.
Conclusion
Each roofing brand brings its own strengths, tailored to different homeowner needs. The best choice for roofing shingles often depends on your priorities – whether that’s affordability, durability, or protection against specific weather conditions.
GAF stands out as a market leader, supported by its Golden Pledge warranty. This makes it an excellent option for those seeking a reliable product paired with a vast contractor network and long-term coverage[2].
For areas prone to high winds, Owens Corning shines thanks to its SureNail fastening technology, which provides added durability in challenging conditions[14].
If premium aesthetics and longevity are your top priorities, CertainTeed is a popular pick, offering shingles with a lifespan ranging from 25 to 50 years[6].
On the budget-friendly side, TAMKO delivers dependable performance at $70–$90 per square, making it a practical option for rental properties or cost-conscious projects[3]. Similarly, Atlas earns praise as a value-driven choice, especially in humid climates. Its Scotchgard Protector treatment effectively combats algae growth, a common issue in coastal and southern areas[6].
When selecting shingles, consider your local climate. For hurricane-prone regions, look for shingles rated for 130 mph winds. In humid areas, prioritize products with algae resistance. If you live in a hail-prone zone, go for impact-resistant shingles with UL 2218 Class 4 ratings.
Lastly, proper installation is crucial. Hiring certified installers not only ensures your shingles are installed correctly but also maximizes their performance and longevity.