Your roof is your home’s first line of defense against weather. Choosing the right shingles can save you from costly repairs and extend your roof’s lifespan, which can range from 10 to 50 years depending on the material. Here’s what you need to know:
- Cost: Reroofing a home costs $9,513 on average, with prices ranging from $5,867 to $13,211.
- Durability: Top-rated shingles last significantly longer and withstand more extreme conditions than lower-rated options.
- Energy Savings: Light-colored shingles can lower cooling costs by up to 15%.
- Warranty: Many "lifetime" warranties only offer full coverage for the first 10 years.
This guide reviews leading brands – CertainTeed, GAF, Owens Corning, Atlas, and Malarkey – based on durability, cost, warranty, and weather protection. Each brand has strengths and trade-offs, so your choice should align with your budget, climate, and long-term goals.
Quick Comparison
| Brand | Durability (Wind/Impact) | Cost per Square | Warranty Highlights | Energy Features |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| CertainTeed | Up to 130 mph / Class 4 | $90–$170 | SureStart (10 years full) | Reflective "cool" shingles |
| GAF | Up to 130 mph / Class 4 | $90–$160 | WindProven (unlimited wind) | ENERGY STAR reflective lines |
| Owens Corning | Up to 130 mph / Class 4 | $80–$200 | Lifetime (with contractors) | Reflective pigments |
| Atlas | Up to 150 mph / Class 4 | $22–$37/bundle | Signature Select (50 years) | Cool Roof Technology |
| Malarkey | Up to 140 mph / Class 4 | $80–$150 | Right Start (10–20 years) | Smog-reducing granules |
Keep reading to explore each brand’s features and find the best fit for your home.
Protect your home with professional roofing services built for long term durability.
2024 Roofing Shingle Guide: Ultimate Review by Roofers
1. Best Shingles Consumer Reports: CertainTeed
CertainTeed has earned its place as a standout in the roofing industry, consistently praised for its durability and performance. Known for its heavy-duty shingles, the brand excels in harsh weather conditions, with its products often ranking among the heaviest on the market. For example, CertainTeed Landmark shingles scored an impressive 4.28/5 overall and a perfect 5/5 for weight in professional testing [5].
Durability
CertainTeed’s patented Triple Laminate Technology, featured in the Landmark TL and Presidential Shake TL lines, results in some of the thickest architectural asphalt shingles available [4]. The Grand Manor line, for instance, weighs over 500 lbs per 100 sq. ft., more than twice the weight of a standard 30-year shingle [4].
For impact resistance, CertainTeed offers the Landmark ClimateFlex and NorthGate ClimateFlex lines. These shingles use ClimateFlex® Technology, a rubberized asphalt blend that enhances flexibility during extreme temperature changes. Both lines have achieved the highest Class 4 impact rating under UL 2218 standards [4].
Cost
Need roof repairs or a full replacement? Explore our trusted roofing solutions.
As a premium brand, CertainTeed shingles come with a price tag that reflects their quality. Material costs range from $90 to $170 per square (100 sq. ft.) [6]. To see how these prices impact your total investment, use a roof replacement cost calculator to factor in labor and local rates. The brand organizes its offerings into three categories:
- Standard Architectural: Landmark AR, PRO, Solaris
- Premium/Luxury: Landmark Premium, Grand Manor, Presidential Shake
- Rubberized Options: ClimateFlex lines [4]
The Landmark PRO, for example, weighs about 270 lbs per square and costs more than the base Landmark line. However, it offers 14 "Max Def" colors with enhanced contrast and richer shadow lines [7].
Warranty Coverage
CertainTeed provides solid warranty options, starting with its SureStart program, which covers 100% of material and labor costs for the first 10 years. For extended, non-prorated coverage, homeowners can opt for SureStart Plus, available when the Integrity Roof System is installed [8][6]. Adding this system with a CertainTeed-certified contractor typically increases the total roof cost by about $1,000 [8]. The top warranty tiers – 5-Star 10 and 5-Star 25 – also include workmanship coverage, protecting against installation errors for 10 or 25 years, respectively [8].
Weather Resistance Features
CertainTeed shingles are built to withstand tough weather. Standard architectural lines are rated for winds up to 110 mph, while premium options can be upgraded to handle winds of 130 mph [7]. The brand also incorporates StreakFighter technology, using copper-infused granules to prevent algae stains, with a 15-year algae warranty included [7]. Additionally, the CertaSeal adhesive enhances wind resistance by preventing uplift during storms [7].
For energy-conscious homeowners, the Landmark Solaris line uses reflective granules to reduce solar heat absorption, potentially lowering cooling costs – a feature gaining traction as energy efficiency becomes a priority [4]. With these advanced features, CertainTeed sets a high bar for durability and performance, leading seamlessly into the next brand review.
2. Best Shingles Consumer Reports: GAF
GAF dominates about 32% of the North American market, installing shingles on roughly one out of every three homes [9]. Their flagship product, the Timberline HDZ series, stands as the top-selling architectural shingle in North America, offering a mix of durability and a wood-shake aesthetic [6]. GAF products are easy to find at major retailers like Home Depot and Lowe’s, making them accessible for contractors and homeowners who prefer to tackle projects themselves [3].
Durability
GAF’s architectural shingles feature LayerLock Technology, a system that mechanically binds shingle layers for added strength, improving both wind resistance and structural durability [9]. The Timberline HDZ shingles weigh about 255 lbs per square, providing solid protection thanks to their thicker construction. To simulate long-term wear and tear, these shingles undergo rigorous lab testing, including 500 hours of UV exposure and water sprays [2].
For areas prone to hail, GAF offers the Timberline HDZ IR (Impact Resistant) shingles, which carry a Class 4 impact rating [9]. This added resilience can often lead to insurance discounts for homeowners.
Cost
GAF shingles are priced between $90 and $160 per square for materials alone [6]. Installed costs vary depending on the product line:
| Product Line | Type | Cost per Sq. Ft. (Installed) |
|---|---|---|
| Timberline NS | Entry-level Architectural | $3.50 – $5.00 |
| Timberline HDZ | Flagship Architectural | $4.50 – $6.50 |
| Timberline HDZ RS+ | Reflective (Cool Roof) | $5.00 – $7.50 |
| Timberline UHDZ | Ultra-High Definition | $5.50 – $8.00 |
| Grand Sequoia | Designer (Wood Shake look) | $8.00 – $12.00 |
| Camelot | Designer (Slate look) | $8.50 – $13.00 |
For a typical 2,000-square-foot roof, installation costs usually range from $7,000 to $15,000 or more, depending on factors like roof complexity and additional system components [10].
Warranty Coverage
GAF provides a Lifetime Limited Warranty, which offers full replacement coverage for the first 10 years before transitioning to prorated coverage [3]. Their WindProven warranty delivers unlimited wind protection [9][10], but this requires a complete GAF system installation, including specific underlayment and starter strips.
Homeowners who hire Master Elite certified contractors can access the Golden Pledge warranty. This includes 25 years of No-Dollar-Limit (NDL) coverage for both materials and workmanship [9]. Additionally, GAF offers a 25-year StainGuard Plus algae warranty, the longest in the industry [9]. For those installing GAF’s solar shingles, a 30% federal tax credit is available until the end of 2025 [3].
Weather Resistance Features
Standard Timberline HDZ shingles are rated to withstand winds up to 130 mph. However, when installed with the WindProven system, they offer unlimited wind speed protection [9]. The shingles also feature the StrikeZone Nailing Area, a wide and visible zone that ensures accurate fastening, which is critical in maintaining wind warranties in storm-prone regions [9].
GAF’s StainGuard Plus technology includes a 25-year warranty against blue-green algae streaks [9]. For high-UV areas like Florida, the Timberline HDZ RS+ line incorporates reflective granules that meet ENERGY STAR standards, helping reduce cooling costs [9]. In fact, GAF earned a 9/10 performance score for Florida’s challenging climate, which includes hurricanes, high humidity, and intense UV exposure [9]. Additionally, GAF’s Timberline Solar shingles combine photovoltaic technology with a traditional roof appearance, thanks to their innovative design with perpendicular bars across the array [3].
With its strong market presence and focus on balancing performance with affordability, GAF continues to set a high standard in roofing. Next, we’ll look at how Owens Corning compares.
3. Best Shingles Consumer Reports: Owens Corning
Owens Corning’s Duration® Series has become a standout in the roofing world, earning recognition as the "Best Performance" brand for 2026 [6]. What sets it apart? Its patented SureNail® Technology. This wide, engineered fabric strip reinforces the overlap between the fabric, shingle, and common bond, creating a triple-layered design that 9 out of 10 professional roofing contractors prefer [11].
Durability
The SureNail® strip delivers exceptional fastener holding strength, which helps resist wind uplift and supports a 130 mph wind warranty [11]. During independent testing, these shingles scored a perfect 5/5 in both the Pull Test (simulating wind resistance) and the Granule Loss evaluation, leading to an overall rating of 4.44/5 [12].
For areas prone to hail, Owens Corning offers two Class 4 impact-resistant options. The Duration FLEX® line uses SBS polymer-modified rubberized asphalt, making it more flexible in cold temperatures. Meanwhile, the Duration STORM® line incorporates WeatherGuard® Technology, which uses a polymeric backing for enhanced impact resistance [11][13]. Both options weigh over 250 lbs per square, boast four to five material layers, and are designed to prevent cracking while maintaining granule adhesion [14].
Cost
Owens Corning shingles are priced to cater to a variety of budgets. Most product lines range from $80 to $150 per square [6][15]. The Oakridge® line is an affordable architectural option, while the Duration® Series falls in the mid-to-high range [13]. For those seeking premium designs, products like Woodmoor® and Berkshire® are priced between $150 and $200 per square [14]. For an average home, installed costs typically range from $9,500 to $13,000 [15].
| Product Line | Type | Material Cost per Square |
|---|---|---|
| Supreme® (3-Tab) | Entry-level | $80 – $100 |
| Oakridge® | Builder-grade Architectural | $80 – $110 |
| Duration® Series | High-performance Architectural | $110 – $130 |
| Duration FLEX® | Impact-resistant (SBS) | $90 – $110 |
| Duration STORM® | Impact-resistant (WeatherGuard) | $110 – $130 |
| Woodmoor®/Berkshire® | Designer/Premium | $150 – $200 |
Warranty Coverage
Owens Corning offers a Lifetime Limited Warranty that includes full replacement for the first 10 years, followed by prorated coverage [3]. To qualify, shingles must be installed by a licensed Owens Corning contractor [3]. Some products also feature StreakGuard® Algae Protection with its own warranty [11]. Homeowners using Platinum Preferred contractors gain access to enhanced warranty options, including workmanship protection and the Total Protection Roofing System®. This system integrates shingles, underlayment, starter strips, and vents to maximize durability and ventilation [14][15].
Weather Resistance Features
Owens Corning shingles are built with a multi-layer design: a fiberglass base for strength, asphalt for waterproofing, and ceramic granules to deflect UV rays and prevent early wear [3]. For hot climates, the Duration® COOL and TruDefinition® COOL shingles use reflective pigments to cut cooling costs by up to 15% [14][3]. These reflective options can bounce back 30% to 60% of sunlight, with white versions reflecting as much as 60% to 90% [3]. In colder climates, the SBS rubberized asphalt in the Duration FLEX® line helps prevent cracking and tearing [11][13]. For snowy areas, adding an ice-dam protection membrane on the decking is recommended to stop water seepage [3].
Owens Corning also keeps aesthetics in mind, naming "Evergreen Mist" as its 2026 Shingle Color of the Year – a testament to its balance of performance and design [11].
Next, let’s take a closer look at what Atlas shingles bring to the table in terms of value and reliability.
4. Atlas
Atlas shingles deliver reliable performance designed to withstand severe weather, all while being budget-conscious. The brand’s StormMaster and Pinnacle Impact lines stand out with a Class 4 impact-resistance rating – the highest available – which makes them an excellent choice for homeowners in areas prone to hailstorms [16][19]. Features like double-bond adhesive and a heavier-than-average weight further enhance their ability to endure harsh conditions [17][18].
Durability
Ensure your home stays protected with expert roofing installation and maintenance.
Atlas Pinnacle Pristine shingles earned a perfect 5/5 in professional pull-tests and weight consistency evaluations, achieving an overall score of 4.55/5 [18]. These shingles measure 42 inches wide with a 6-inch exposure, allowing them to cover more area compared to some competitors [17]. For wind resistance, most Pinnacle lines are rated for speeds up to 130 mph, while the StormMaster and Castlebrook lines can handle winds as high as 150 mph [16][19].
To combat algae-related black streaks, Atlas incorporates 3M Scotchgard Protector (StreakGuard) directly into the granules, rather than using a surface treatment. This innovative approach ensures long-lasting protection and is backed by a 25-year to lifetime algae warranty [16][17][21].
Cost
Atlas offers a range of pricing options to suit various budgets, from economical to premium. Installation costs typically fall between $5.50 and $12.00 per square foot, with full roof replacements averaging $10,500 to $16,500 [16][17]. If you opt for the high-performance StormMaster line, expect to add $1,000 to $1,500 to your total cost [19].
Material costs per bundle vary depending on the product line:
- GlassMaster (3-tab): ~$22 per bundle
- Castlebrook (Architectural): ~$24 per bundle
- Pinnacle Pristine (Architectural): ~$27 per bundle
- StormMaster Shake/Slate (Premium Architectural): ~$37 per bundle
For those looking for a balance of cost and performance, the Pinnacle Pristine line is a solid mid-range choice, priced about 15% to 25% lower than CertainTeed Landmark shingles [21].
| Product Line | Type | Wind Warranty | Impact Rating | Approx. Cost/Bundle |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| GlassMaster | 3-Tab | 60 mph | Standard | ~$22 |
| Castlebrook | Architectural | 130 mph | Standard | ~$24 |
| Pinnacle Pristine | Architectural | 130 mph | Standard | ~$27 |
| StormMaster Shake | Premium Architectural | 150 mph | Class 4 | ~$37 |
Atlas shingles provide a strong mix of affordability and weather-ready performance, making them a top choice for many homeowners.
Warranty Coverage
Atlas offers a Lifetime Limited Warranty that includes a 10-year non-prorated coverage period [16]. For extended protection, the Signature Select warranty provides a 50-year non-prorated guarantee, but it requires the installation of the full Atlas roofing system, including underlayment, ventilation, and flashing [16].
According to Integrity Home Exteriors:
Atlas is the only manufacturer with 3M Scotchgard protection for the shingle’s entire lifespan.
They also shared:
Atlas consistently honors legitimate claims without excessive bureaucracy.
With dependable warranty options and a track record of honoring claims, Atlas provides peace of mind for homeowners.
Weather Resistance Features
Atlas shingles are designed to handle extreme weather. The StormMaster line integrates Core4 technology, which includes PolyCore, FlexCore, WeatherCore, and ThermalCore, to resist cracking and impacts [20]. For homes in hot climates, the Pinnacle Sun line uses 3M Cool Roof Technology to reflect UV rays, reducing cooling costs [16]. Eco-friendly options like ProLam and Briarwood Pro even feature smog-reducing granules [16].
However, Atlas shingles seal best when temperatures are above 40°F. In colder conditions, other brands may perform better [19]. Some installers have also noted that the extra tar in the nailing area can occasionally clog nail guns during installation [17].
Next, we’ll take a closer look at Malarkey shingles, focusing on their eco-friendly features and overall performance.
5. Malarkey
Malarkey stands out among top-rated shingles for its combination of eco-conscious design and reliable performance. These shingles are built with NEX Rubberized Asphalt Technology, which uses recycled rubber and plastics to enhance flexibility and reduce cracking during temperature changes. Even their entry-level Highlander line boasts a Class 3 impact rating, while the Vista, Legacy, and Windsor lines achieve the industry’s highest Class 4 rating [22][24].
One homeowner in Naperville, Illinois, shared a telling example: their Malarkey Vista shingles sustained only minor cosmetic damage during a 2-inch hailstorm, while a neighbor’s roof was completely destroyed [22].
Let’s break down Malarkey’s performance in key areas like durability, cost, warranty, and weather resistance.
Durability
Malarkey shingles deliver exceptional durability, with tear strength improvements ranging from +10% on the Highlander line to +40% on the Windsor line [24]. Independent lab tests gave the Vista shingles a perfect 5/5 for weight, nailing zone consistency, and overall reputation, earning them an impressive 4.5/5 overall rating [23]. The wider nailing zone also reduces the risk of installation errors that could lead to leaks or blow-offs [23][24].
These shingles are built to withstand winds of up to 110 mph on standard lines and up to 140 mph on the Windsor designer line [22][24]. For algae protection, Malarkey uses copper-coated granules, with the premium Legacy and Windsor lines featuring Scotchgard Protector to combat black streaks. Additionally, their smog-reducing granules provide air-cleaning benefits equivalent to planting two trees per roof [22][24].
Cost
Malarkey shingles are a long-term investment. Installation costs typically range from $5 to $7 per square foot, translating to $8,000 to $11,200 for a 1,600-sq.-ft. roof replacement [22]. Upgrades to premium lines come with additional costs: Vista adds $13–$20, Legacy adds $17–$31, and Windsor adds $36–$51 per 100 sq. ft. [24]. While the initial price is higher, the shingles’ durability and reduced need for repairs make them a smart choice for homeowners planning to stay in their homes for 15 years or more [22].
Warranty Coverage
Malarkey provides a standard non-prorated "Right Start" warranty lasting 10 to 20 years, depending on the product line [24]. For even greater peace of mind, homeowners who use a Malarkey Certified Contractor can qualify for the Emerald Pro Warranty, which extends coverage to 50 years and includes wind protection up to 140 mph [22]. Algae protection warranties range from 10 years on the Highlander line to limited lifetime coverage on the Legacy and Windsor lines. Homes with Class 3 or Class 4 impact-rated shingles may even qualify for insurance discounts [24].
Weather Resistance Features
The NEX Rubberized Asphalt ensures Malarkey shingles remain flexible and resist brittleness during temperature swings [24]. Class 4 shingles like Vista, Legacy, and Windsor are rigorously tested to endure impacts from 2-inch steel balls dropped from 20 feet, simulating hail damage [24]. For areas prone to severe weather, the Legacy and Vista lines are recommended for hail and tornado-prone regions, while the Windsor line excels in coastal zones with its 140-mph wind resistance. In rainy or humid climates, the Legacy and Windsor shingles’ Scotchgard algae protection offers an added layer of security [24].
However, Malarkey does face some challenges. It has less brand recognition compared to larger competitors, offers fewer color and style options, and may have limited availability in certain regions like the Midwest [22].
Despite these drawbacks, Malarkey strikes a balance between durability, sustainability, and long-term value, making it a strong choice for homeowners seeking reliable protection.
Pros and Cons
Every shingle brand has its own strengths and trade-offs. Knowing these differences can help you choose the right roofing option based on your priorities – whether that’s affordability, durability, or convenience. Here’s a quick breakdown to make comparisons easier.
CertainTeed offers a wide range of materials, including asphalt, metal, and faux slate. Their Solstice solar shingles are designed to resemble traditional roofing styles [3]. On the downside, their premium lines come with higher price points, which might be a stretch for homeowners looking for top-tier features on a budget.
GAF is known for being widely available, sold directly through major retailers like Home Depot and Lowe’s [3]. This makes purchasing and project coordination easier. However, their Timberline solar shingles have a less conventional appearance due to perpendicular bars [3]. Additionally, their standard three-tab shingles, like Royal Sovereign, are thinner and less durable compared to architectural options [2].
Owens Corning stands out for its exceptional performance in lab tests, with the Berkshire Collection earning top marks from Consumer Reports [25][1]. Plus, having a licensed contractor install their shingles unlocks lifetime warranty coverage [3]. The trade-off? Their premium collections are among the most expensive, costing around $225 per square [1].
Atlas distinguishes itself with Scotchgard technology in its premium lines, which helps prevent mold and mildew [3]. Their StormMaster Slate shingles provide excellent value at approximately $135 per square [25][1]. However, Atlas doesn’t have as many retail-direct purchasing options as GAF.
Here’s a summary of each brand’s key strengths and drawbacks:
| Brand | Key Strengths | Key Drawbacks |
|---|---|---|
| CertainTeed | Wide material range (e.g., metal, faux slate); Solstice solar shingles resemble traditional designs [3] | Premium lines are more expensive |
| GAF | Easy to buy at major retailers (Home Depot/Lowe’s); offers solar options [3] | Timberline solar shingles have a less traditional look [3]; standard three-tab shingles are thinner [2] |
| Owens Corning | High lab performance; lifetime warranties with licensed installers [3][25][1] | Premium collections are pricey (around $225 per square) [1] |
| Atlas | Scotchgard for mold/mildew resistance; strong value for performance [3][25][1] | Limited retail purchasing options compared to GAF |
Conclusion
When it comes to choosing the right shingles, it’s all about finding the balance between cost, durability, and protection. If you’re on a tight budget, three-tab shingles are a solid option, priced around $100–$200 per square. However, they come with limitations, like wind resistance capped at about 60 mph [2][3].
For a step up, architectural shingles offer a great middle ground. They provide better durability and improved wind resistance while remaining reasonably priced. If you’re seeking maximum protection, multilayered architectural shingles are the way to go. These premium options shine in Consumer Reports testing and can handle winds up to 110 mph. As test engineer Misha Kollontai explains:
In some cases, the material is so thick you’re getting more than triple the protection you’d get from standard shingles.
For added value, Atlas stands out with its Scotchgard mold protection and Class 4 impact resistance, all at competitive pricing [6]. GAF makes things convenient with its wide availability at major retailers like Home Depot and Lowe’s [3]. Meanwhile, Owens Corning excels in lab performance, especially when installed by licensed contractors, which unlocks their lifetime warranty [3].
FAQs
Which shingle type is best for my climate?
The best type of shingle largely depends on the weather conditions in your area. Asphalt shingles are a popular option due to their versatility and durability, performing well in climates with heavy rain, snow, or strong winds. If you live in a region with more extreme weather, metal shingles might be a better fit. They last longer – typically 40 to 50 years – and offer excellent resistance to fire, wind, and moisture. Be sure to evaluate your local weather patterns to make the best decision for your home.
Do “lifetime” shingle warranties really cover my whole roof?
"Lifetime" shingle warranties typically cover manufacturing defects for as long as you own your home. But here’s the catch: they don’t promise that the shingles will last for the entire expected lifespan of your roof. Things like proper installation, routine maintenance, and the surrounding environment all play a big role in determining how long your shingles will hold up.
What else should I budget for besides shingle price?
In addition to the price of shingles, you’ll need to account for several other expenses that could add up quickly. These include the cost of removing your old roof, repairing any damaged decking, obtaining necessary permits, and investing in warranties. You might also face costs for structural reinforcements and extra labor, all of which can heavily influence the overall price of your roofing project.